Thursday, January 14, 2010
Since its creation in 1948, the state of Israel has existed in a state of near-constant conflict, either with conventional threats from neighboring states, or with insurgent activity from occupied territory. The Israeli military has repeatedly proved their ability to combat enemies of a martial nature. Military foes, however, are far from the most pressing concern to the state of Israel. The Jewish majority of Israel, and by extension the Israeli government, is far more focused on the growing non-Jewish population within the borders of Israel. Politically, the rapid demographic growth of this minority is worrisome to the government of Israel, which is facing an ever more difficult attempt to keep Israel as a primarily Jewish state. Various measures have already been enacted that stray disturbingly close to violating the rights of the non-Jewish minority. In addition to the problems within the borders of Israel, the military-occupied territories of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip have become the focus of a bloody conflict between Palestinian and Israeli civilians, both sides attempting to exert their influence and claim as much land as they can. In a misguided attempt to become the ideal of the Jewish state, the Israeli government has come dangerously close to abandoning its responsibility to its populace and its occupied territories, regardless of their demographic or political affiliation.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Good background information. Clear and concise.
ReplyDeleteI am unclear about the responsibility you are referring to when you say, " the Israeli government has come dangerously close to abandoning its responsibility to ..."
Is it to provide security? Peace? or uphold the basic human rights?
-I noticed that you did not mention that Israel is a state that is based on Religion. Did you mean leave this out?
-Israel there is not separation between religion and state, this raises to the question is the Israeli government responsible first to the Jew within its borders or the population as a whole.
Very well stated and great information. Does the fact that Israel is constantly on red alert make their rash actions somewhat acceptable? What is a governments ultimate responsibility to its people?
ReplyDeleteI do not get a clear thesis out of this. Like Bekkah what do you mean by responsibility. Is the Israeli state a free state or is it only free for the Jews. Great background though!
ReplyDeleteThis is really great and very interesting. What exactly is the responsibility of the government? I definitely agree with Bekkah that you would need to touch on the subject of religion.
ReplyDeleteVery informative. I'm also a little unclear about what the government's responsibility entails. What exactly are you arguing in your thesis?
ReplyDeleteGood job on introducing background information. My question is, what is the responsibility that the State has in general to its populace and are Israel's responsibilities any different?
ReplyDeleteThis is a very well written background on the state of affairs, but how exactly does it relate to freedom and responsibility. I didn’t quite see where you’re thesis was nor what your stand on the situation is.
ReplyDeleteVery nice; concise, well- written, and a good contrast between historical information and your own opinions.
ReplyDeleteWhat, specifically, is the Israeli government's "responsibility" to it's populace? who defines such a responsibility? Is Israel's responsibility to those in the Gaza strip, as part of it's occupied territory, the same as its responsibility to those in Jerusalem? Doesn't the Israeli government give inhabitants of Jerusalem a greater amount of political freedom than inhabitants of the Gaza Strip, and is the act of suppressing the freedom of those in the Gaza Strip simultaneously an act of preserving the freedom of those in Jerusalem? Is israel justified in defending its infrastructure from what it sees to be outside threats? Should doing so be seen as a national responsibility or an aggressive display of power?
Just things to think about...
Doesn't Israel face an existential threat every day, from places like Iran? Doesn't everyone have a beef with Israel? I personally feel that this validates a lot of their wrong doings. I would like you to address the point that it is tough being Israel.
ReplyDeleteGREAT first paragraph, it really grabs the reader, and gives helpful background information.
ReplyDeleteI'm a little unsure what the argument is here though.
Agree with Shane in that it would be hard to be "the Jewish state" and then to feel that it was being taken away.
This is a a really interesting issue. I like that you chose something that is rarely discussed, but you provided the background needed and your writing was easy to understand.
ReplyDeleteI had trouble locating your thesis. What was your argument and why?